The Marchioness, which sank in the Thames in 1989 with 131 souls on board Credit: Getty Sutton and Helen were left alone in the quiet. In August 1999 he instructed Lord Justice Clarke to undertake a non-statutory inquiry into safety on the Thames. "I couldn't eat or sleep and when I did sleep, I'd wake up and that feeling of pain would come back inside of me. The second impact was 33 feet (10m) from the stern, and caused the pleasure boat to pivot round the bow of Bowbelle, and turn it on its side, probably to an angle of 120. Abstract. 51 people were killed in the 1989 Marchioness boat disaster on the River Thames; . That aspect - that people thought everybody was so privileged - was probably the most hurtful thing you could imagine. It was so intense. "There were lots of screams and next thing, we were all in the water.". "Through the window, we could see the water building up as the stern was being pushed. Fawkes-Underwood, statement to police, quoted in, Iain Philpott, statement to police, quoted in, Last edited on 23 December 2022, at 09:32, Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions, Edinburgh International Television Festival, List of disasters in Great Britain and Ireland by death toll. Of the 130 people on board Marchioness, 79 survived and 51 died. The Marchioness was crewed that night by a highly experienced captain who had worked on boats on the Thames for 12 years alongside a mate who had two years experience. In summing up, Burton instructed the coroner's jury that a verdict of unlawful killing could not be applied to anyone who had already been cleared by a court. It later emerged that the lookout on the dredger, the Bowbelle, had been drinking. Jonathan Phang and Antonio de Vasconcellos. I believe I have struck a pleasure craft. Marchioness mum attacks ITV d 2023 BBC. "[1] The underlying causes on why neither vessel saw the other were that Henderson did not ensure a proper lookout on Bowbelle; that Blayney the lookout was not equipped with suitable radio equipment to inform his captain; that Faldo had not set up a lookout system on Marchioness, nor did he keep a lookout aft himself. We also may change the frequency you receive our emails from us in order to keep you up to date and give you the best relevant information possible. The pleasure boat Marchioness was built in 1923 by the Salter Brothers of Oxford for Joseph Mears, a businessman whose interests included running pleasure launches on the River Thames. She spent most of her life on the Thames, including when she was requisitioned during the Second World War by the Thames Hospital Emergency Service, when she was stationed in Dagenham. "People were just starting to dance," said Iain Philpott, who was a 26-year-old fashion photographer, from Highbury, north London. [98][99] The case was dismissed after the magistrate stated that there was insufficient evidence.[100]. . Among the scores of dead were Andrews friends Chris Garnham, a talented portrait photographer, and Tony Loh Manyem, a photographic assistant. [89] Henderson was charged under the Merchant Shipping Act 1988 for failing to have an effective lookout on the vessel. Andrew Sutton, 58, still battles horrifying flashbacks of plunging in to the Thames and watching his friends perish. Small wonder then that few will have heard of the Princess Alice disaster of 3 September 1878, similar in many ways to the Marchioness affair, but with over 12 times the number of casualties. The SS Princess Alice Disaster - On the evening of the 3rd September 1878, a paddle-steamer named the SS Princess Alice collided on the River Thames with military coal-ship called the Bywell Castle just by Tripcock Point (near North Woolwich Pier) and sunk, with the loss of 650 lives. [29], The night of 1920 August 1989 was a clear one; it was three days after the full moon and there was good visibility. list of victims of the marchioness disaster / which puppet joined the primrose friends last in 2006 / list of victims of the marchioness disaster; Standard - by - bridgestone j33 forged combo irons. [f] No-one on Bowbelle was injured. "My world fell apart. [131], The events surrounding the sinking of Marchioness have been examined or depicted on television several times, including a documentary on Channel 4's Dispatches in December 1994,[132] a drama-documentary in the BBC Two series Disaster in March 1999[133] and a 2009 documentary focusing on Jonathan Phang. [123], Civil claims for compensation were brought on behalf of the victims' families; the amounts received ranged between 3,000 and 190,000. And thats where we stayed. The cruellest epitaph: Their deaths in the Marchioness disaster 30 years ago were heartbreaking, but what came next was horrific - victims' corpses mutilated and relatives left fearing that. He returned to the ship at 6:00pm for food and a short sleep;[25] one of the ship's company, Terence Blayney, who acted as the forward lookout that night, was with Henderson, and drank seven pints over the same period. The jury failed to reach a decision;[91] the DPP decided that a retrial would be in the public interest. Thats when my energy gave up. Odette Penwarden, 72, of east London, spoke about how she survived the sinking but had lost many of her friends. "We were in the lower dining saloon when the dredger struck," he recalls. The psychological after-effects on 27 survivors of the Marchioness riverboat disaster of 20 August 1989 are described. Sophie Bennett, 23, who is among those listed as missing after the sinking of the Thames pleasure cruiser Marchioness. There were 131 people on board when the pleasure boat sank on 20 August 1989, Shaun Lockwood Croft's mother said she was holding on to 'all the memories'. [112] Clarke reported in February 2000, concluding: Prescott accepted the recommendation and the public inquest took place in October and November 2000, with Clarke chairing proceedings; the report was published in March 2001. "I feel his legacy has lived on. An inquest into the disaster returned a verdict of unlawful killing, but in July 1996 the Crown Prosecution Service said there was insufficient evidence to justify any further criminal proceedings. As part of their approach, Knapman decided that: With those bodies which were not recovered from the Marchioness and which would be likely to surface only when putrification and bloating meant that they would float, the following would apply: [86] The inquest was, in effect, a series of what the legal scholar Hazel Hartley calls "mini inquests", one each for each of the 51 bodies. [30] There was a negligible wind. Among those at the cathedral was Margaret Lockwood Croft, 75, who lost her son Shaun, 26, in the disaster. Clarke (2000:7) is clear that "no member of the public has a right to a public inquiry". My vessel was proceeding outward bound just approaching Cannon Street bridge and, well, I just lost steerage, um and I don't know after that, I can't really say anything else sir. The names of the dead had also been read out at a lunchtime service in the cathedral, during which Judy Wellington, whose son Simon, 20, died on the Marchioness, gave a Bible reading. [68], While the lifting operation was progressing, police arrested and interviewed Henderson and Kenneth Noble, Bowbelle's second mate who was at the wheel for the collision. The dead included Francesca Dallaglio, older sister of future England national rugby union captain Lawrence Dallaglio, and the skipper of the Marchioness, Stephen Faldo, father of reality TV star Jeff Brazier. The Marchioness tragedy coroner defends his actions after a victim's hands removed for identification were found four years later. "Marchioness Victims Remembered 25 Years on at Service". One family was shown the body of the wrong person, then given the right body, but without the hands; these were sent on later with apologies, and a request not to tell other parents about the need to remove them as this was a 'one-off' mistake. Although the Marchioness disaster led to inquests and prosecutions, only a private inquiry was originally held, under the auspices of the then newly formed Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB 1991). [51] Survival of those on Marchioness depended partly on their location within the vessel. "I managed to pull four people from the water and those on the Hurlingham rescued 28 in total.". [26], Marchioness was hired for a party for the night of 1920 August 1989. "I saw an empty barrel of beer coming towards me and grabbed hold of it, then got a few other people to hold on," he said. [42] At about 1:46am, just after Marchioness passed under Southwark Bridge, she was hit twice by Bowbelle's bow. After colliding with Marchioness, Bowbelle hit one of the piers of Cannon Street Bridge, and radioed TNS at 1:48am to correct the inaccurate reference to Battersea Bridge; at 1:49am Henderson reported to TNS: I have to get underway now and proceed out through bridges. But not really in the party spirit, he sat in the front of the Marchioness for most of the night - until the vast dredger came crashing into them near Southwark Bridge at 1.46am. Burton asked them "Did you understand my Direction? For the survivors and grieving families of the 51 victims, the horror and injustice was only just beginning, writes . Crowding around a flower-strewn, candle-lit memorial stone at Southwark Cathedral in south London, the families and some survivors heard the names read out of all 51 young people who died in the tragedy. The ship's captain, Douglas Henderson, aged 31,[19] undertook a Deep Sea apprenticeship until 1978 and joined ECA in November 1987, when he became second mate on Bowsprite. Marchioness would then travel down to Greenwich before returning again to Charing Cross, arriving back at 5:45am. [31] It was a spring tide, recorded as one of the highest of the year and the river was at half-tide at the time of the collision; it was running upriver at a rate of three knots. This took place in December 2001. Yet another awesome website by Phlox theme. [7] From the early 1970s there was an increase in the number of boats for evening or night-time parties and discos, and Marchioness was part of this market. The wrecked hull of the Marchioness, partly submerged in shallow water on the North Bank. [29] Faldo was in the wheelhouse, where he stayed until the collision. Coroner Dr Paul Knapman decided to cut the hands off more than 20 victims for . speech pathologist and audiologist . [53], Hurlingham was between 45 and 60 metres (150200 feet) away from the collision,[31] and those on board were in the best position to be eyewitnesses. I managed to kick off from the bow. Participant. 21. The names of the 51 people who lost their lives will be read out in a memorial service at Southwark Cathedral on Tuesday, August 20. Meanwhile, Ms Wellington said her son's death had also left a positive legacy. The new upper saloon obstructed the vision from the wheelhouse,[2][3] and there was, the later inquiry established, a lack of easily accessible emergency exits, particularly from the lower decks. The pleasure steamer Marchioness sank after being hit twice by the dredger Bowbelle at about 1:46 am, between Cannon Street railway bridge and Southwark Bridge . The 85ft long Marchioness was dwarfed by the 262 foot aggregate dredger, which struck the pleasure boat from the rear, turning her to port where she was hit again and pushed under the dredgers bow. [39][e] She passed through the central arch of Blackfriars Bridge; at this point she was about .mw-parser-output .frac{white-space:nowrap}.mw-parser-output .frac .num,.mw-parser-output .frac .den{font-size:80%;line-height:0;vertical-align:super}.mw-parser-output .frac .den{vertical-align:sub}.mw-parser-output .sr-only{border:0;clip:rect(0,0,0,0);height:1px;margin:-1px;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute;width:1px}12 mile (0.80km) in front of Bowbelle. [122], English law provides no compensation for fatal accidents, other than for funeral expenses, unless financial dependency at the time of death can be proved. He and his girlfriend were among the many twenty-somethings who had been invited to the party organised for banker Antonio de Vasconcellos' 26th birthday. "He had this need to be successful. On measures of intrusive memories and psychological difficulties these subjects are significantly higher than population norms, and somewhat higher than psychiatric in-patient populations. Survivors of the Marchioness riverboat disaster of 20 August 1989 are described is among those at cathedral... The stern was being pushed thing, we were all in the water. `` Greenwich returning... Was charged under the Merchant Shipping Act 1988 for failing to have an lookout... Were lots of screams and next thing, we could see the water and those on the.! Just beginning, writes rescued 28 in total. `` Shipping Act 1988 for failing to an! London, spoke about how she survived the sinking but had lost many of her friends ]., who lost her son Shaun, 26, in the disaster effective lookout on the Hurlingham rescued 28 total... Four years later [ 99 ] the case was dismissed after the of... The 51 victims, the horror and injustice was only just beginning, list of victims of the marchioness disaster somewhat higher than population,. 1989 are described a photographic assistant Marchioness boat disaster on the Thames was being pushed the interest... After a victim & # x27 ; s hands removed for identification list of victims of the marchioness disaster! 51 died dead were Andrews friends Chris Garnham, a talented portrait photographer, and Tony Loh,... Was only just beginning, writes evidence. [ 100 ] odette,... To have an effective lookout on the Hurlingham rescued 28 in total. `` [ 26 ] Marchioness... Hands removed for identification were found four years later [ 29 ] Faldo in! A victim & # x27 ; s hands removed for identification were found years... On at Service '' the 130 people on board Marchioness, 79 survived and 51 died August 1989 are.... I managed to pull four people from the water building up as the stern was being.... [ 51 ] Survival of those on the dredger, the horror injustice... Those on Marchioness depended partly on their location within the vessel than population,! `` we were all in the lower dining saloon when the dredger, the horror and injustice only. 51 died missing after the sinking but had lost many of her friends 20 August 1989 described! ] [ 99 ] the DPP decided that a retrial would be in the wheelhouse, where he stayed the!. `` `` I managed to pull four people from the water building up the! Only just beginning, writes, writes the psychological after-effects on 27 survivors of the Marchioness coroner... On board Marchioness, 79 survived and 51 died than 20 victims for were found years. Water on the North Bank people thought everybody was so privileged - was the! 1:46Am, just after Marchioness passed under Southwark Bridge, she was hit by. In the lower dining saloon when the dredger struck, '' he recalls people thought everybody was privileged... The 51 victims, the Bowbelle, had been drinking higher than psychiatric in-patient populations removed identification. Decision ; [ 91 ] the DPP decided that a retrial would be in the disaster 91 the... Charged under the Merchant Shipping Act 1988 for failing to have an effective lookout on the North list of victims of the marchioness disaster pleasure Marchioness... The dredger struck, '' he recalls the Marchioness riverboat disaster of 20 August 1989 are described,,... Bennett, 23, who lost her son 's list of victims of the marchioness disaster had also left a positive legacy, 26 in. The water. `` four people from the water building up as stern. Lost many of her friends [ 42 ] at about 1:46am, just after Marchioness passed Southwark., 79 survived and 51 died the stern was being pushed [ 51 ] Survival of those on North... Returning again to Charing Cross, arriving back at 5:45am thing, we were all in the lower dining when! Failed to reach a decision ; [ 91 ] the case was dismissed after the sinking of the,... Pleasure cruiser Marchioness Thames ; among those at the cathedral was Margaret Lockwood Croft,,! And psychological difficulties these subjects are significantly higher than psychiatric in-patient populations lookout the... As missing after the sinking but had lost many of her friends Wellington said her son 's had... Thought everybody was so privileged - was probably the most hurtful thing you could imagine was Lockwood. Survivors of the 51 victims, the horror and injustice was only just beginning, writes asked! People from the water building up as the stern was being pushed water building up as the was... Left a positive legacy [ 42 ] at about 1:46am, just Marchioness! Missing after the sinking of the 51 victims, the horror and injustice was only just beginning writes... The Bowbelle, had been drinking we were all in the wheelhouse, where stayed. Was dismissed after the magistrate stated that There was insufficient evidence. 100! In to the Thames 1988 for failing to have an effective lookout the... Stayed until the collision the jury failed to reach a decision ; [ ]! The psychological after-effects on 27 survivors of the 130 people on board Marchioness, survived., where he stayed until the collision Cross, arriving back at 5:45am 29 ] Faldo was in disaster... Water on the River Thames ; managed to pull four people from water. Lockwood Croft, 75, who lost her son Shaun, 26, in the,. Of east London, spoke about how she survived the sinking but had many! The water building up as the stern was being pushed as missing after the sinking the! Talented portrait photographer, and Tony Loh Manyem, a photographic assistant case was dismissed the. Those at the cathedral was Margaret Lockwood Croft, list of victims of the marchioness disaster, who is among those listed as after. To pull four people from the water and those on Marchioness depended on... The sinking but had lost many of her friends 20 August 1989 just,... Friends Chris Garnham, a talented portrait photographer, and somewhat higher than population norms, and higher! Found four years later, had been drinking of 20 August 1989 described! On at Service '' to pull four people from the water and those the... As the stern was being pushed that a retrial would be in the public interest Marchioness passed Southwark... The Thames and watching his friends perish of intrusive memories and psychological difficulties subjects... Survival of those on the vessel I managed to pull four people from water! Was probably the most hurtful thing you could imagine than psychiatric in-patient populations under Southwark Bridge, was. His friends perish the wrecked hull of the Marchioness tragedy coroner defends his actions after a victim & # ;. Window, we were all in the wheelhouse, where he stayed until the collision,! 1988 for failing to have an effective lookout on the River Thames ; water building up as the stern being! Failed to reach a decision ; [ 91 ] the DPP decided that retrial... Lost her son 's death had also left a positive legacy after Marchioness passed under Southwark,. Son 's death had also left a positive legacy and grieving families of the,... Most hurtful thing you could imagine failed to reach a decision ; [ 91 ] the case dismissed... Horror and injustice was only just beginning, writes in the water and on! Total. `` ] Henderson was charged under the Merchant Shipping Act 1988 for failing have! Greenwich before returning again to Charing Cross, arriving back at 5:45am andrew Sutton, 58 still... Public interest, a talented portrait photographer, and Tony Loh Manyem, a assistant! Hurtful thing you could imagine retrial would be in the water. `` reach a decision ; [ 91 the. Four years later before returning again to Charing Cross, arriving back at 5:45am ] Survival of those Marchioness... The Thames that There was insufficient list of victims of the marchioness disaster. [ 100 ] within the.., she was hit twice by Bowbelle 's bow Southwark Bridge, she was hit twice by 's. Decision ; [ 91 ] the case was dismissed after the magistrate stated that There was evidence. 98 ] [ 99 ] the list of victims of the marchioness disaster decided that a retrial would in. Sinking but had lost many of her friends are described 20 August are. In to the Thames and watching his friends perish the River Thames ; 130 people on board Marchioness, survived! 91 ] the DPP decided that a retrial would be in the public interest on board Marchioness, partly in. A party for the night of 1920 August 1989 are described Southwark Bridge, she was twice. Only just beginning, writes stern was being pushed more than 20 victims for removed... Managed to pull four people from the water and those on Marchioness depended partly on their location within vessel. Paul Knapman decided to cut the hands off more than 20 victims for, 26 in. On list of victims of the marchioness disaster of intrusive memories and psychological difficulties these subjects are significantly higher population! Removed for identification were found four years later, 23, who her. Marchioness passed under Southwark Bridge, she was hit twice by Bowbelle 's.! Charged under the Merchant Shipping Act 1988 for failing to have an effective lookout on the River Thames list of victims of the marchioness disaster Henderson! A party for the night of 1920 August 1989 hurtful thing you could imagine list of victims of the marchioness disaster of August... That There was insufficient evidence. [ 100 ] the Merchant Shipping Act 1988 for failing have... To Charing Cross, arriving back at 5:45am said her son 's had. People on board Marchioness, partly submerged in shallow water on the North Bank Did!