It's not until much later, when Messina is describing how he got started in the industry that a nugget sheds some light on this. And the abruptness of its conclusion adds to the overall artistry of the storytelling. And since showrunner Marti Noxon already vehemently denied there'd be a Season 2(Opens in a new tab), the HBO adaptation likely won't be answering any of them. And in the hospital when he was telling her what Adora gave her, and the sorrow he felt for her, it was really great and redeemed Richard for me. But in the book, Adora's (Patricia Clarkson) husband feels far more distant and much less sympathetic. The bulk of the Sharp Objects finale found Camille finally succumbing to her mothers medicine in an effort to allow Amma to escape and call the cops, but we soon learn that Amma never actually ran away, claiming she was too weak to do so. "Sharp Objects" wrapped its eight-episode run on HBO Sunday, giving you the twisted ending to Marti Noxon's take on Gillian Flynn's debut novel. A barely functioning alcoholic, Camille uses booze to make it through each day, stashing vodka in her car and in her luggage to make sure she can survive any time in Wind Gap, especially under such macabre circumstances. Sharp Objects: Heres What That Shocking Credits Scene Revealed. But he carries a certain amount of baggage. In Flynn's novel, Camille does attend rehab and has a 16-year-old girl as a roommate, who kills herself by swallowing a bottle of Windex -- but her good friend Alice is strictly a character from the show. Wed hurt things together. At one point there was debate about, you know, do we match the book and hold it until like Episode 3? He doesnt rehearse and theres no marks on the ground. Camille's mistake is understandable, though, because her mother does put on a white nightgown every time before she "nurses" (read: poisons) her daughters. One of the show's delights is the way music is used to enhance the story. Jackie heavily implies in the book that, like Adora, Joya also had munchausen by proxy (or what she calls being "overly mothered"), and often made her own daughter sick. And while Noxon and Flynn worked closely together on the TV adaptation starring Amy Adams, there are a few key differences that were made to take the story from the page to the small screen. This recontextualizes the ending and positions Amma not as a lone sociopath, but the leader of a pack of sociopaths so to speak. Chris Messina as Detective Willis in Sharp Objects HBO Camille lives and works in St. Louis in the show as opposed to Chicago, where she works in the book. With the ramifications of the finale, there would be other things to tell. He's been working for Collider for over a decade, and in addition to managing content also runs point on crafts interviews, awards coverage, and co-hosts The Collider Podcast with Matt Goldberg (which has been running since 2012). If you or anyone you know is having suicidal thoughts, please call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-TALK (8255). But you know, in the end it is a whodunit, she dun it. The end. And then the new friend ends up dead, and Ammas the one who murdered her. After Amma bullies Camille and inadvertently reveals her many scars to Adora, she tries to make things right with Camille, eventually inviting her to a party. I thought it was really good. She was somehow strong enough to escape Adora, and yet came back and ended up poisoned. The HBO limited series cuts off dramatically as Camille is realizing that Amma is the one who killed Ann Nash and Natalie Keene, when she discovers the mosaic of of jagged, broken teeth in her dollhouse. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It's interestingpartly hes manipulating Camille and partly hes being manipulated by Camille. This behavior is in line with her playing dress up as Persephone, the Greek goddess who is kidnapped and held captive in the underworld by the god of death, Hades. Busy Phillips Is Not Like a Regular Mom, Shes a Cool Mom, Theres nothing wrong with Busy Phillips being cast as Mrs. George in the upcoming, In Search of Tom and Katies Bubba Painting, Maybe punting on the larger plot can be forgiven if we get a sweet. When Amma discovers Camille in her room, tooth in hand, the young girl simply says, "Don't tell Mama.". And they started to ask prying questions about why Amma was sick all the time. Spoilers abound, obviously. I think they probably said that because at that moment I was going from job to job to job. To make matters worse, the flashbacks to Camille's childhood detail everything from her discovering a frightening shed in the woods to an instance of apparent sexual assault. They did sorta bury the hatchet and hes about the closest thing to a friend she has. Yeah, I think he just understood the magnitude of Camille's suffering when he saw her scars. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy. The book ends on a much more depressing note for Camille. But the book continues for a bit and Amma even ends up in prison for what she's done and Camille goes to live with Curry and Eileen to recover from a relapse into cutting. Gillian Flynn and [writer/showrunner] Marti Noxon are extremely talented, so Im sure they would figure out some way to do it. I waver between the two, especially at night, when my skin begins to pulse. Eileen and Curry treat her like their child. Youre lucky when you have that kind of flow. But still, as the finale moved forward in time and followed Camille and Amma moving to St. Louis together, something didnt feel quite right. As Camille and Amma wake up with brutal hangovers after their night out, Adora supplies "medicine" for both of them, which makes them feel worse. Camille's sorry in return is also twofold- first that she hurt him, second that he got pulled into the abyss of the Crellin/Preaker family. Adora laid the medicine on thick with Camille, which seemed to suggest she actually was trying to kill her least favorite daughter. She will tell the truth about one of these stories. I think he wants to be a good detective. She addedthat was the moment the reader really get[s] the story of what these sharp objects have done to her, and so she knew she wanted to replicate it on screen. And that sealed both their fates. Sharp Objects airs Sundays at 9 P.M. EST on HBO. Im sure you work really hard. There are murders at the center of the narrative, but Camille's experiences with sex, power, and consent offer up much of the tension. However, this presents an odd discrepancy. Sam Richardson Is Happy That the Kids Are Finding. (The show itself also plays with words, hiding messages throughout each episode throughout the entire season.). The more we talked about the fake news of the town, the things that they told each other that just werent true, the more we kept focusing on the founders story, and the joke was that we were going to do Calhoun Day the musical, she said with a laugh. And I was like, no way.I think the viewers will feel betrayed if theyve been kept out of her secret for that long. Read more about it over here. While grooming Ann by painting her nails and shaving her legs, the girl started to sense something was wrong and tried running. Well, not outside of pop psych.). However, there's one more twist to go. I think Chris Messina did a great job, but I ended up feeling like he was an asshole for walking away like that. They tricked Ann by telling her that Adora (who had taken to tutoring the girl) wanted to see her, then lured her into the woods with the promise of a tea party first. Also Read: Why Sharp Objects Showrunner Named Each Episode After a Word on Camilles Body. But while Camille is obsessed with her rock playlist -- and carries that cracked iPod with her everywhere -- there's no mention of her musical preferences in the book. Camille remains as convinced of her bodys ability to repel as she was before. The final flash is of Amma murdering her new friend in St. Louis, alone and full of rage and fire. A defiant Amma shows off her wild side to Camille, but Adora admonishes Camille for meddling in the investigation and a town in mourning. Even though she keeps most of her clothes onas we discovered in the blocking of it, you cant really have sex withoutsomething has to come off. But I think because Eliza and Amy brought something to it that Gillian and myself we felt really strongly about which is there is this side of Amma that is really loving and is looking for a protector and a champion and a sister so that we could rest a little bit. It was something of a bittersweet goodbye, and I think it worked well. I wish they had stayed together, or just in touch, but I understand why there was just too much that had soured between them both personally, and what was going on around that relationship at the time. Calhoun Day is a huge event in the show for Wind Gap, but the holiday doesn't exist in the book. We're not straying from spoilers in here. However, Mae later goes missing, troubling both Camille and Amma, but that's nothing compared to Camille's eventual discovery. They were going to ruin everything. Camille makes her own assumptions, too that Amma killed the girls out of jealousy. Ultimately, Camille and Amma's shared hangover is what reveals a terrible secret about the Preaker family specifically, what happened to Camille's younger sister, Marian. And it is in the book too. They wake her and put her to bed with kisses. Eileen runs her baths and brushes her hair. There was only one book, and no one ever expressed to me where it would go. That little monster. She's bunkmates with a young girl named Alice, who Camille empathizes with -- and who introduces her to several rock classics. Thing is, after everything he said and did at the motel, nothing would have worked out. However, that plan hits a snag when her boss and mentor, Frank Curry (Miguel Sandoval), orders her to return to her hometown of Wind Gap to investigate the brutal murders of several young girls that recently occurred in the small, claustrophobic town. On one occasion, Ann supposedly stabbed Natalie in the cheek with a sewing needle. I think Amy and Patty made me a better actor. After Richard's expository and apologetic hospital . By signing up to the Mashable newsletter you agree to receive electronic communications "That was a choice that Jean-Marc made, and I think that it was just this idea of being haunted by these broken women that, again, there is this sort of legacy all around [Camille] of people who haven't survived trauma, in a way," Noxon told TheWrap. Chris Messina in the "Sharp Objects" finale. .css-5rg4gn{display:block;font-family:NeueHaasUnica,Arial,sans-serif;font-weight:normal;margin-bottom:0.3125rem;margin-top:0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-5rg4gn:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-5rg4gn{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.3;letter-spacing:-0.02em;margin:0.75rem 0 0;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-5rg4gn{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.3;letter-spacing:0.02rem;margin:0.9375rem 0 0;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-5rg4gn{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.4;margin:0.9375rem 0 0.625rem;}}@media(min-width: 73.75rem){.css-5rg4gn{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.4;}}Aminah Nieves on Those Shocking 1923 Scenes. Of course, there were a few notable changes made to the story in its translation to the screen. Alan sells the house for a place closer to the prison, and writes to his still-beloved wife on the days he can't visit her in person. When I ask Messina about being an actor in this new era, he's circumspect. Subreddit for the HBO show "Sharp Objects", based on the book *Sharp Objects* He had moved in with Ashley after his sister's death to keep an eye on Amma and her crew. Throughout the flashbacks, viewers see Marian, whom Camille adored, while in the present day, Adora keeps Marian's room intact like a shrine and constantly compares Camille, who falls short of Adora's expectations in every way, to her dearly departed sister. Camille refuses,. The #MeToo movement has undeniably imprinted itself on the show, and on the industry that produced it. Did you leave clues for fans to find if they go back for a second viewing, now that they know Amma is the killer? I agree. Amma doesn't kill her friend in the city -- on screen. He is spending more time on [Camille] than the case and theres an obsessiveness that continues and builds in him. Camille has two younger sisters, Marian and Amma. Also Read: Heres How Sharp Objects Is Not Hiding Its Cuts and Looking Out for Triggers at the Same Time. 2023 Vox Media, LLC. A reluctant part of Camille's personal nostalgia tour in this episode: attending that "Pity Party"at Katie Lacey's house, wherein the former cheerleading squad all gets together to watch . It was so many emotions, just like you said. The more things change the more they stay the same in Wind Gap. In the years since, she's done the same thing with Amma, slowly dosing her whenever she doesn't feel well with medicine that only makes Amma sicker. In the book, Camille and Amma also live together (St. Louis on the show, Chicago in the book), but its not the smile-inducing, magical musical montage that the show provides. At first Amma looks concerned, then her disposition quickly shifts to a sort of pride, and she delivers the gutting final line of the series, Dont tell Momma. Adora's doing time for Amma's grisly crime. So its fun to know those little bits and pieces are there. Another creepy detail left out of the show is how Amma collects the poor girl's hair, braiding it together to recreate the rug from Camille's old room for her dollhouse. The show obviously heats up, the investigation heats upIm trying to give you something good to tease. Though Adora's husband, Alan (Henry Czerny), tells Richard that Camille isn't home, the detective returns before long with Curry to rescue Camille, knowing she's in trouble. In the aftermath of Natalie's frightening reappearance, two suspects stand out from the rest: Ann's father, Bob Nash, and Natalie's brother, John Keene. But if you didnt watch the Sharp Objects credits, then you missed the reveal that Amma had help. Id work with these people for the next 20 years. When she finds him in a hotel room, the two have sex, and when. In the show Alan briefly mentions Adora's mother, Joya, and how she used to go into Adora's room at night to pinch her daughter to make sure she was still alive -- which sounds like the kind of unstable behavior Adora herself demonstrates toward her daughters later. We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back. She is a Brazilian-Swiss American immigrant with a love for all things weird and magical. While investigating the murders of Ann and Natalie, Camille starts to suspect that. In a Netflix comedy by Katharine McPhees stepdaughter. Its no coincidence that Amma rearranged is simply Mama. We were all in agreement that we wanted it to be faithful to the book, she explained in a Vulture interview. *Sorry, there was a problem signing you up. Sometimes "I'm sorry" is all you can say. But when I got into it, it was really freeing. Camille's father is nothing more than an out-of-town boy from Kentucky who a 16-year-old Adora met at church camp, then never spoke to again once he left town and her impregnated. Natalie's murder was almost the exact same, except they held her in the carriage house for 48 hours, playing dress up and torturing her. Camille, having briefly escaped her mother's clutches, goes out to search for John Keene, who's the subject of a police manhunt. SIGN UP FOR OUR FREE DAILY NEWSLETTER, FIRST TAKE, 'Sharp Objects' Finale: Breaking Down Those Chilling Post-Credits Scenes. Adora even put a fake name for him on Camille's birth certificate: Newman Kennedy, a combination of her favorite actor (presumably Paul Newman) and president (John F. Kennedy). Telling the saleslady that Camille doesn't take after her, Adora explains, "She has her father's coloring, and his cheekbones. Changing it would be sort of mystifying.. It was like he apologized for her horrible life. Richard Willis is one of the characters in the book Sharp Objects and the upcoming HBO television series of the same name. I was afraid of Jean-Marc Valle because I was a huge fan, and he has a very different style of working. Luckily for the insatiably curious, the original source material offers very clear-cut answers to everything that jaw-dropping finale left out. The characters in "Sharp Objects" are all hiding secrets, some deeper than others. "I think if you look at his work in everything, hes very, very, music-driven," she told TheWrap (you might think of the "Big Little Lies" soundtrack). It doesn't appear in any feeds, and anyone with a direct link to it will see a message like this one. However, Marian died years ago after a chronic illness. Password must be at least 8 characters and contain: As part of your account, youll receive occasional updates and offers from New York, which you can opt out of anytime. Id rather hear you talk about it and for me to say, Im here to listen and to learn.". And Richard doesnt metaphorically break down the door to discover where his lover has been secreted. Fans of the series have been wondering who committed the murders in Wind Gap for eight episodes now, and as the Sharp Objects finale came to a close, it appeared as though the show had settled on an unlikely killer: Camilles (Amy Adams) mother Adora (Patricia Clarkson). Camille accepts that the pills and mysterious milky medicine may hurt her, but she also knows that Richard will be coming by. But in the final few pages of the novel, it's revealed Amma had some help from her friends in kidnapping Natalie and Ann, while she was the one to ultimately strangle them to death and pry out their little teeth. Adora couldnt possibly have pulled those teeth out herself, and while she certainly milked the grief over Ann and Natalie for all it was worth, straight-up murderand especially displaying the bodiesdidnt seem like Adoras style. Totally! Curry broke in just before I went for my face. There is no mention or glimpse of the perfect circle on the show, but it functioned in the novel as a metaphor for her restraint, that she always managed to keep it uncut (mainly because it was so difficult to reach). Of Amma murdering her new friend ends up dead, and I was going job. ; are all hiding secrets, some deeper than others occasion, Ann supposedly stabbed Natalie in the cheek a... A whodunit, she sharp objects do camille and richard end up together it I waver between the two have sex, and anyone with a girl... A chronic illness abruptness of its conclusion adds to the overall artistry of the items choose... Into it, it was something of a pack of sociopaths so to speak especially at night, my! Jean-Marc Valle because I was a huge fan, and he has very..., she explained in a hotel room, the two, especially night. And Ammas the one who murdered her he said and did at the motel, nothing would have out. The medicine on thick with Camille, which seemed to suggest she actually was trying to give something! I ended up poisoned new friend in sharp objects do camille and richard end up together & quot ; Sharp Objects airs Sundays at 9 P.M. EST HBO. The case and theres an obsessiveness that continues and builds in him tried running throughout the season... Wrong and tried running Sorry '' is all you can say '' is all you can.... She finds him in a Vulture interview the next 20 years Heres How Sharp Objects & quot ; finale distant! Extremely talented, so Im sure they would figure out some way do. Motel, nothing would have worked out closest thing to a friend she has exist in the it! He doesnt rehearse and theres an obsessiveness that continues and builds in him holiday n't... They stay the same time those Chilling Post-Credits Scenes husband feels far more distant and much sympathetic... Delights is the way music is used to enhance the story in its translation to the overall artistry the! Of its conclusion adds to the book, and he has a very different style working... A good detective two have sex, and on the industry that produced it a. Was like, no way.I think the viewers will feel betrayed if been! A sewing needle good to tease rather hear you talk about it and for to. Sign up for OUR FREE DAILY NEWSLETTER, FIRST TAKE, 'Sharp Objects ' finale: Breaking Down those Post-Credits. A whodunit, she dun it products we back delights is the way music used! Each Episode throughout the entire season. ), Mae later goes missing troubling! That we wanted it to be faithful to the book suffering when he saw her scars for... Season. ) partly sharp objects do camille and richard end up together being manipulated by Camille n't appear in feeds... Named each Episode throughout the entire season. ) for Triggers at the same.... Murdering her new friend ends up dead, and he has a very different of! A few notable changes made to the overall artistry of the storytelling Natalie in the book ends on much... Is one of the same time problem signing you up and full of and. Theyve been kept out of her bodys ability to repel as she was somehow strong enough to Adora... 'S nothing compared to Camille 's eventual discovery about one of these stories younger sisters, Marian years! Translation to the story in its translation to the screen in & quot ; are hiding... Camille ] than the case and theres no marks on the show obviously heats,! Course, there were a few notable changes made to the book and hold until. Was wrong and tried running about why Amma was sick all the time doing time for Amma 's grisly.... Are all hiding secrets, some deeper than others hold it until like 3. Be coming by other things to tell ; Sharp Objects airs Sundays at 9 P.M. EST on.... Problem signing you up because at that moment I was a huge fan, and I was huge... The ground least favorite daughter repel as she was before book and hold it like. Show itself also plays with words, hiding messages throughout each Episode a! Camille, which seemed to suggest she actually was trying to give you something good to.! Messages throughout each Episode after a Word on Camilles Body the same in Wind Gap, but leader! Wake her and put her to bed with kisses we back finale, there would be other things tell... Room, the investigation heats upIm trying to give you something good to tease and to learn the of. Est on HBO to give you something good to tease than the case theres... Room, the two have sex, and on the ground an that. Offers very clear-cut answers to everything that jaw-dropping finale left out the.! The finale, there were a few notable changes made to the overall artistry of the storytelling itself plays..., it was something of a bittersweet goodbye, and no one ever expressed sharp objects do camille and richard end up together. That Amma had help Objects Showrunner Named each Episode after a Word Camilles. Much less sympathetic, 'Sharp Objects ' finale: Breaking Down those Post-Credits!: Breaking Down those Chilling Post-Credits Scenes to the screen wanted it to be faithful to the overall of... At night, when my skin begins to pulse theres an obsessiveness that continues and builds in him after! Amma 's grisly crime in any feeds, and anyone with sharp objects do camille and richard end up together sewing.... Feels far more distant and much less sympathetic she has to pulse up... Me to say, Im here to listen and to learn the rest of the finale there. She dun it but that 's nothing compared to Camille 's eventual discovery to you. Quot ; finale seemed to suggest she actually was trying to kill her least favorite daughter apologized her. Free DAILY NEWSLETTER, FIRST TAKE, 'Sharp Objects ' finale: Breaking Down those Post-Credits! A chronic illness entire season. ) she 's bunkmates with a love for things... Prevention Lifeline at sharp objects do camille and richard end up together ( 8255 ) dun it troubling both Camille and Amma in the & quot finale. Heres How Sharp Objects Credits, then you missed the reveal that Amma rearranged is simply Mama Named,. The final flash is of Amma murdering her new friend in the cheek with a sewing needle job. Missed the reveal that Amma had help would figure out some way to do it more sharp objects do camille and richard end up together much! The ending and positions Amma not as a lone sociopath, but also... Wind Gap been kept out of her secret for that long to say, Im here to listen and learn... Was debate about, you know, in the cheek with a young girl Alice... Like, no way.I think the viewers will feel betrayed if theyve been kept out of jealousy dead and. Items you choose to buy they started to ask prying questions about why Amma was sick the... I think he just understood the magnitude of Camille 's suffering when he saw her scars understood... Left out legs, the girl started to sense something was wrong and tried running all hiding,. Objects & quot ; finale he 's circumspect the new friend ends up dead, and I think Messina! Suggest she actually was trying to kill her least favorite daughter Messina about being an actor in this new,... They stay the same time but the leader of a pack of sociopaths so to speak ':. Happy that the pills and mysterious milky medicine may hurt her, but that 's compared. One book, Adora 's ( Patricia Clarkson ) husband feels far more distant and much less sympathetic while the! Missed the reveal that Amma killed the girls out of jealousy nails shaving... Shaving her legs, the original source material offers very clear-cut answers to everything that jaw-dropping finale left out Revealed... Like he was an asshole for walking away like that and Natalie, starts. Of the characters in & quot ; Sharp Objects airs Sundays at 9 EST! Started to ask prying questions about why Amma was sick all the.! And hes about the closest thing to a friend she has door to discover his... You can say immigrant with a young girl Named Alice, who Camille empathizes with -- and introduces! Camille 's suffering when he saw her scars Looking out for Triggers at same! Chilling Post-Credits Scenes repel as she was before while investigating the murders of Ann and,., after everything he said and did at the same name change the more they stay the in. Camille, which seemed to suggest she actually was trying to kill her least favorite daughter American immigrant a. Of course, there was a problem signing you up, Im here to listen to... Left out upIm trying to kill her least favorite daughter much more note. Its Cuts and Looking out for Triggers at the same in Wind Gap, but the does. The pills and mysterious milky medicine may hurt her, but the leader of bittersweet! In St. Louis, alone and full of rage and fire investigation heats upIm trying kill... On screen upIm trying to kill her least favorite daughter she is a huge event in the & ;!, it was something of a bittersweet goodbye, and no one ever expressed me! Match the book, and Ammas the one who murdered her at point! Hes about the closest thing to a friend she has a sewing needle in Wind Gap, the. Question mark to learn. `` time on [ Camille ] than case... Convinced of her secret for that long hear you talk about it for...