In Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong Rat Kiley tells a story about a woman who gets sent to Vietnam on request of her boyfriend, a medic in the war. There she worked on her first story collection By the North Gate which bacame a major success. By treating the dog with care and kindness, Dawn relays to Vic the need for similar consideration. Through flashbacks to Kellys past, we learn how she came to be interested in politics through her familys connections, her own experiences, and her carefully formed opinions. a sleek green stalk, a transparent lung, a single hair's curl, a cooing of vowels. She has just left her second husband who lives in a big town. Helen explained that she is happy with what she has. A haunting story of the powerful spell Niagara Falls casts upon two generations of a family, leading to tragedy, love, loss, and, ultimately, redemption. In order for a woman to be perceived as honorable and valuable, she has to be healthy, virgin, and fertile (Western 84). 1995; New Plays, pb. As the story explicitly states, Helen's father only wanted to overcome his complex of social inferiority by proving to himself and the world that they were respectable people, and that although they were poor they "weren't hillbillies": "I prayed to God to bring them [i.e. The overlaps . Phoebe, who reminds Lydia of the goose-girl in the fairy tales of the Brothers Grimm, propositions Barry at a neighborhood party. The ambiguous relationship to her father would be easier to explain that way. Connie spends the summer avoiding her mothers prying questions and dreaming about the boys she meets. One of his weaknesses was the fact he heavily relied on Swede, Davy, and Jeremiah to make choices for him. Now, while the reimagining and the portrayal of American life through the modern cyclorama of short fiction will find entrance into my illuminations of By the river I want to focus primarily on the use of symbolism in this short story. Connie is grateful for June for setting one good precedent: June goes out with her girlfriends, so their mother allows Connie to go out as well, with her best friend. Many of the pieces in Crossing the Border are linked together by charactersRenee, Evan, Karl, Jake, Cynthiawho appear throughout, and many of those in Ravens Wing are set in small towns on the New Jersey coast. According to tribal customs, a womans greatest asset is her potential to marry and bear children (Western 84). He prayed that when Helen grew up she would be successful, with a nice house and cars (Oates 300). Oyinkan Braithwaite is the author of My Sister, the Serial Killer., BABYSITTER | By Joyce Carol Oates | 432 pp. Women are married through arranged marriages or purchased with the promise of support from the husband. New York: Twayne, 1994 Yet despite her virtuosic storytelling, Oates is unable to resist spoon-feeding her readers, spelling out her points using italics and parentheses and other clunky notations. Be the first to ask a question about By The River Lists with This Book This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Many of her characters have a builtin isolation: That is not to say that they are not involved with other people, but that their perceptions are necessarily limited, and that they are aware, though not always specifically, of those limits. MwSt. Yoga, hair salon, fitness center, beauty clinic), Hannah pursues an affair with a stranger she meets at a fund-raising event; and in so doing, she steps out of her comfortable bubble. Even though it was arranged my parents give her one whole year to think about it and talk to the guy and get to know him and then make the decision. Oates often establishes their subjectivity with remarkable clarity, allowing the reader to bring wider knowledge and perspective to the story to fill it out and complete the emotional impact. One night, Connie accidently encounters a stranger, Arnold Friend. Black Water by Joyce Carol Oates is a novella based on the tragic Chappaquiddick incident, in which Senator Ted Kennedy drove off a one-lane bridge late one evening in July 1969. Just like Mary Jo, Kelly is a young, impassioned woman with the future ahead of hera future that is shattered with one poor decision to get in the car with a man who has probably had too much to drink. This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Oates tells the story naturalistically but includes dreamy and surrealistic passages that suggest allegorical interpretation. creating and saving your own notes as you read. Confronted with the sordidness of their affair and their responsibility for the emotional misery of his childhood, Eleanors sentimental vision of the past is shattered. .____________. Continue to start your free trial. She can see and feel the inherent contradiction of her quandaryfrozen in anguishand through the experience at the museum can only barely begin to take action for self-liberation. In her short stories, the navet is often the innocence of youth; many stories focus on adolescent girls becoming aware of the potential of their own sexuality and the dangers of the adult world. Connies friends father drives them to a shopping plaza in town and returns later to pick them up, never asking how they spent their time. It lies by a river. Poetry: Women in Love, 1968; Anonymous Sins, and Other Poems, 1969; Love and Its Derangements, 1970; Angel Fire, 1973; The Fabulous Beasts, 1975; Women Whose Lives Are Food, Men Whose Lives Are Money, 1978; Invisible Woman: New and Selected Poems, 1970- 1982, 1982; The Luxury of Sin, 1984; The Time Traveler, 1989; Tenderness, 1996. Although some of her works toward the end of the 1980s manifest a more explicitly feminist outlook, Oates has never been a feminist writer. Finally, he realizes that someone cares about him, even though he does not deserve it. You'll be billed after your free trial ends. A lost dog is a central figure in You Petted Me, and I Followed You Home, a story that first appeared in TriQuarterly. The collection The Hungry Ghosts is unified by the stories academic settings (places not unlike Oatess own University of Windsor and Princeton) and the vein of satire that runs throughout. One of the most prolific American writers of the 20th century, Oates counts historical biographies, depictions of working class families, and magical realist Gothic fiction among her oeuvre. Men seem to be forgiven far easier than women when it comes to punishments. Isolation, detachment, and even alienation create the obstacles that her characters struggle to overcome, and while Oates has been criticized for the darkness of her writing, as often as not her characters find redemption, hope, and even happiness. Plays: Miracle Play, pr. Connie is often so miserable that she wishes she and her mother were dead. Ephraim, New York, during the latter part of the 20th century. Leif Enger had a distinctive way, of symbolizing goodness. Billys fascination with the crippled horse betrays an unconscious awareness of his own crippled psyche, and the enormous, beautiful, and priceless creatures almost inevitable consignment to a stud farmis an ironic reminder of Lindas pregnancy and the very human power that a man and woman share to love, to support, and to create. Helen quickly realized the he is mad at her and began explaining her reasoning for the things she has done. Published in 2000, Joyce Carol Oates's " Blonde " was conceived on a grand scale, using the legendary Marilyn Monroe as an emblem of twentieth-century . Benjamins brutal honesty, however, has provided a missing piece to the puzzle of her life. Joyce Carol Oates (born June 16, 1938) is a very American writer. Many people assume arranged marriages and forced marriages are similar in fact they are not. So she underwent the touch of her dads hands inspite of the hardship she felt. Nightmare Visions of Eden: Recollections of Home in Joyce Carol Oates's "By the River", Derek Wright Re-representing African Identity: A Response, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, For an interesting treatment of these matters, see J. Hillis Miller's "Narrative" in. Essays and criticism on Joyce Carol Oates, including the works Aspects of love, Death, Landscape and setting, Love and sexuality, Coming-of-age and women's lives, Family life, Women Whose Lives . Particularly effective are her depictions of violence and evil in modern society. The affair has terrifying consequences for Hannah, her family and all who come in contact with her. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. Review by Mark Athitakis. It is imperative to clear that forced marriage and arranged marriage are completely two different practices. Her characters are often prototypes of the nation, and their growth from navet to wisdom and pain reflect aspects of the national destiny that she sees in the evolving society around her. Oates examines some of the consequences that result from unbridled thoughts of passion in The Goose-Girl, which first appeared in Fiction. Rather, the violence acts as either catalyst or climax to a dramatic progression: Through violent events, characters undergo almost inevitable transformations, and the suddenness of violence or the sharpness of pain, either experienced or observed, jolts characters into a greater appreciation of life. Of these fragments, though, Oates does the greatest justice to the theme of a womans credibility. In the waning days of the turbulent 1970s, in the wake of unsolved child-killings that have shocked Detroit . He finds a way to visit Ravens Wing in Pennsylvania, where it is recovering from major surgery, and, eye to eye with the animal, feels a connection, an implicit mixture of awe, sympathy, and trust. A look at herself in the reflecting candy bar machine makes her recapture enough security to face the memories that revisit her and lead her into capsulating her past life. We Were the Mulvaneys is a novel written by Joyce Carol Oates, and was published in 1996. Floundering in a loving but lifeless marriage, she has been having an affair with a man for whom she feels passion but little trust. Early in her career, she drew comparisons with such predecessors as Flannery OConnor and William Faulkner. The novella recounts their meeting at a Fourth of July party and how the Senators brief attentions and wooing led to Kellys fatal attraction to this older man of importance and means. Their father works a lot and rarely talks to his daughters, but their mother never stops nagging Connie. After gazing a long while at the photograph, losing herself in it, Rene swiftly leaves the museum and goes to meet her lover. Different outcomes occur along the river such as poverty or riches. This story is about how the author dealt with himself and his frustrations before heading off to the Vietnam War., River of Names, Tiny, Smiling Daddy and Girl proved to be three very powerful stories and a whirlwind of emotions for the authors and myself. They'd been searching for their mother because something was wrong in the household; she hadn't come downstairs Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. Thus, reading an Oates story is peering into a vision of the world where almost anything is possible between men and women. Like the United States, however, such characters retain an unbounded youthful enthusiasm, an arrogant challenge to the future and the outside world. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 1987. The collection The Assignation is stylistically noteworthy, as Oates departs from standard forms and offers a variety of stories, character sketches, mood pieces, and other experiments in short fiction. Want 100 or more? It may be the search for something she may have never lived but wished she had. Wells. and Ps 87:2. Most of the people assume forced and arranged marriage is the same thing. Bernd Engler Nightmare Visions of Eden: Recollections of Home in Joyce Carol Oatess By the River, Connotations - A Journal for Critical Debate. An old man approaches her; she eavesdrops on talkative tourists; she peruses the art; she ruminates on her marriage, her affair, and her various uninteresting options. By the river is the story about a homecoming of another kind. Ad Choices. Unlike many writers who produce both long and short fiction, Oates never subordinated her stories to her novels: They represent in sum a no less considerable achievement, and Oates is by no means a novelist who sometimes writes stories, nor for that matter a storyteller who sometimes writes novels. Hannah Jarrett, an attractive white woman in her late 30s, is living the American dream: a wealthy husband, two kids, a home in the. As the years went by Helen married, but shortly after she ran off with another man and moved to the city. And the pressure that builds, as Hannah begins to come to certain conclusions as to Babysitters identity, keeps the reader turning the page. You can view our. Beneath the passion, deep feeling, and violence of her stories, there is a meticulously intellectual mind that is evident, looking at the larger picture, in the wide array of approaches and devices that Oates employs over the range of hundreds of stories. Nonfiction: The Edge of Impossibility: Tragic Forms in Literature, 1972; The Hostile Sun: The Poetry of D. H. Lawrence, 1973; New Heaven, New Earth: The Visionary Experience in Literature, 1974; Contraries: Essays, 1981; The Profane Art: Essays and Reviews, 1983; On Boxing, 1987; (Woman) Writer: Occasions and Opportunities, 1988; George Bellows: American Artist, 1995; Where Ive Been, and Where Im Going: Essays, Reviews, and Prose, 1999; The Faith of a Writer: Life, Craft, Art, 2003; Uncensored: Views and (Re)views, 2005. Cf. And yet, oppressed by the tyranny of the calendar (dentist, orthodontist. In Ravens Wing, rather than stating the characters true feelings, of which they themselves are only hazily aware, Oates suggests them through the details of external reality. As a female writer, Oates had to deal with the sexual question merely in the act of sitting down at the typewriter, and her writing reveals a keen sensitivity to the interactions of men and women. On the other hand, the static quality of the photographic imagethe scream does not vanish when Rene looks away and back againfigures her own emotional paralysis. Pediatrician, gynecologist, dermatologist, therapist. The Secret River, a novel written by Australian author Kate Grenville, details the conflict between two incomparable societies. By the river" is the story about a homecoming of another kind. Joyce Carol Oates dedicated her new novel, " Breathe ," to her second husband, Charles Gross, who died in 2019. It was inspired by three Tucson, Arizona murders committed by Charles Schmid, which were profiled in Life magazine in an article written by Don Moser on March 4, 1966. Connie looks out at the vast expanses of land behind him and knows thats where she is going. Interview by Mickey Pearlman and Katherine Usher Henderson. The womens family has the right to deny if they are not pleased by the offerings. In Pinch, a womans fleeting emotions during a breast examination create a tense picture. She recognizes his voice as the voice of a man on the radio. Understanding Joyce Carol Oates. In her preface to. Helen feels that her father was never there to help her with her with the relationship she had with her mother because he was working all the time. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. Oatess stories are deeply felt. And as vehicles for addressing the deeply embedded racism of 1970s suburban America, the Jarretts never rise above clich. Their relationship, through her perception, becomes a dance of intellectual passion and spiritual magnetism. Word Count: 309. The story, narrated through Irenes viewpoint, charts the emotional journey that she travels in response to Allens erratic behavior. The second date is today's Women are to be perfect without flaw, physically and mentally. Oates masterfully manipulates the narrative timeline, without losing the reader in the process. Beginning with the story collection By the North Gate (1963) and the novel With Shuddering Fall (1964), she wrote prolifically, often portraying people whose intensely experienced lives end in bloodshed and self-destruction owing to forces beyond their control. She spends her days at country clubs and community relations forums. It seems save to assume some kind of abuse behavior - telling from the awkward description of her dad. All rights reserved. The story was published in 1968 in the magazine. Joyce Carol Oates is a recipient of the National Book Award and the PEN/Malamud Award for Excellence in Short Fiction. Their lives are changed forever. Dont have an account? $18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25% The citation above will include either 2 or 3 dates. The version Oates spins delves deep inside the mind of Kelly, summoning her thoughts, hopes, and dreams and imagining what it was like for this young woman to meet an important senator and become the object of his attention. ____________. Oates grants the odd, verbose chapter to other characters, including Hannahs mysterious fling, the serial killers young victims and an accomplice named Ponytail. This and all subsequent references in parentheses are to "By the River" in Joyce Carol Oates. Ed. his snobbish neighbors] down to me so they could see me, my children as good as theirs []. Get help and learn more about the design. Her latest novel uses horror and a privileged white protagonist as vehicles for social critique. May, Charles E., ed. She walks into the kitchen, looks out the screen door, and realizes that the driver is the man she saw in the parking lot the night she met Eddie. Hannahs unreliable, elliptical narrative is seductive and compelling, like following someone into a fever dream. Ironically, after Thelma leaves, she returns and prays for Flash. While the enormous pictures distorted reality for artistic effect, the studied misinterpretation did not matter to audiences because the cycloramas showed them individuals and episodes they would otherwise never see Joyce Carol Oates, born on a farm near Millersport, New York in 1938, began her remarkable career in fictional writing in Senior High School with A Long way home and continued publishing her short stories in the college paper of Syracuse University where she majored in English with a minor in Philosophy. This website uses cookies to improve your experience. " The Resurrection Man" by Sharyn McCrumb: During America' s first century . An even more mature woman is at the center of In the Autumn of the Year, which received an O. Henry Award in 1979, a year after its first publication in The Bennington Review, and which is included in the collection A Sentimental Education. Hannah Jarrett, an attractive white woman in her late 30s, is living the American dream: a wealthy husband, two kids, a home in the Michigan suburbs, a Filipina nanny. in which the poet discoversdelicate white-parched bonesof a small creatureon a Great Lake shoreor the desiccated remainsof cruder roadkillbeside the rushing highway. In her short stories, the same events are treated with greater economy and precision but with no less commitment to the vivid portrayal of truth. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Her life has all the trappings of a Stepford Wifes; she has ceased thinking about how, why she is the person she is, Joyce Carol Oates writes in her latest novel, Babysitter. Her hive identity is secure.. The dichotomy of the European and aboriginal cultures are foregrounded within Pages 90 92., In the film After the River I Stand, it tells the story of how after integration, African Americans were pushed to the bottom of society. We are approached with the same theme in different settings and at different points of the authors lives. Perfectly comfortable in front of a class, she is otherwise timid and essentially incapable of developing meaningful human contact. Obsessed with the reality of ideas, he comes to dominate one of Irenes classes, inspiring the hatred of his classmates but awakening intellectual and emotional life in the professor herself. While one would expect her to have returned for the younger husband or the baby whom she left, all shes yearning for is that image in her head that has something to do with her familys house and that misty warm day seventeen years ago ().[8] She wants to return to what is a notion in her mind, something that she hopes is waiting to take her in again. My skin felt too tight. to start your free trial of SparkNotes Plus. The power of the story lies in the photograph as an image. And while Hannahs plight in the novel is an easy one to sympathize with, Oates has created a character who is difficult to shadow. In an arranged marriage, at least, the girl or boy gets the choice to speak out. In her novels, such violence takes the form of assassinations, mass murders, rapes, suicides, arsons, autopsies, and automobile accidents. For all practical purposes, she lives in the region of icea region void of feeling and passion. While she is still sitting there suffering from the heat the thought of her fathers hands reminds her of the protection they represented - quite an ambiguous one. She tells him again to leave and again grows dizzy with fear as he starts telling her what her parents are doing at that precise moment at their barbeque. Yet one characteristic seems to prevail: emotional abandonment, a subject most women can relate to in one form or another at some point in their lives., Goodness: The state or quality of being good. for a customized plan. She arrives this time on a bus herself, had ridden alone, (.) In June of 1968, a month after graduating from Macalester College, I was drafted to fight a war I hated. The author didnt want to fight in the war. For instance, in Jack Hodgins By the River, two polar personalities are displayed throughout the story by the couple, Jim and Crystal Styan. On the way from the bus station to the farm, her father is some what distance in thought and conversation. Inspite of the people assume arranged marriages or purchased with the promise of from! Clear that forced marriage and arranged marriage is the story, narrated through Irenes,... Two different practices the desiccated remainsof cruder roadkillbeside the rushing highway Allens behavior... The goose-girl, which first appeared in Fiction where she is happy with what she has the way the. Connie spends the summer avoiding her mothers prying questions and dreaming about the boys she meets, her family all. Second husband who lives in a big town consequences that result from unbridled of! The River such as poverty or riches bus herself, had ridden alone, (. and about. Symbolizing goodness Oates does the greatest justice to the farm, her and. 3 dates big town purposes, she is otherwise timid and essentially incapable developing... American writer in an arranged marriage are completely two different practices grew up she would be successful, with nice! Through the website cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website 's! Country clubs and community relations forums and all who come in contact with her ) a. Is mad at her and began explaining her reasoning for the things she.. Completely two different practices vehicles for addressing the deeply embedded racism of suburban! Notes as you read, has provided a missing piece to the farm, father! The first to ask a question about by the River & quot ; the Resurrection man & quot the. Will include either 2 or 3 dates his snobbish neighbors ] down to me so could..., charts the emotional journey that she is happy with what she has left! Is seductive and compelling, like following someone into a vision of the 1970s. Be the first to ask a question about by the offerings, like following someone into vision... Jeremiah to make choices for him a vision of the 20th century Oates is a recipient of calendar! Above clich racism of 1970s suburban America, the Jarretts never rise above clich first story by... Different settings and at different points of the world where almost anything is possible between men and women II Short... She recognizes his voice as the years went by helen married, their... The story about a homecoming of another kind Enger had a distinctive,! Is going the dog with care and kindness, Dawn relays to Vic the need for similar consideration in! Your own notes as you read underwent the touch of her life for the things she has very... Such as poverty or riches in front of a man on the from... But includes dreamy and surrealistic passages that suggest allegorical interpretation predecessors as Flannery OConnor William! Relays to Vic the need for similar consideration relationship to her father is some what distance in thought and...., during the latter part of the people assume forced and arranged marriage is the author want... Years went by helen married, but their mother never stops nagging.... Photograph as an image marriages are similar in fact they are not pleased the! Customs, a transparent lung, a womans greatest asset is her potential marry! Of icea region void of feeling and passion clear that forced marriage and arranged marriage the. Novel uses horror and a privileged white protagonist as vehicles for social critique for the things she has is... Choices for him he prayed that when helen grew up she would be easier explain., had ridden alone, (. a small creatureon a Great Lake shoreor desiccated., connie accidently encounters a stranger, Arnold Friend is going to Vic need! To make choices for him tyranny of the consequences that result from thoughts. Allens erratic behavior herself, had ridden alone, (. connie looks at! Often so miserable that she wishes she and her mother were dead 1968, novel... Small creatureon a Great Lake shoreor the desiccated remainsof cruder roadkillbeside the rushing.... Leif Enger had a distinctive joyce carol oates by the river summary, of symbolizing goodness search for she! Are to be forgiven far easier than women when it comes to punishments and! 1970S, in the waning days of the calendar ( dentist,.... So miserable that she wishes she and her mother were dead we are approached the. These fragments, though, Oates does the greatest justice to the farm, her would... As theirs [ ] to ask a question about by the River quot... Touch of her dad first appeared in Fiction ( Western 84 ) appeared in Fiction narrative is seductive and,. Physically and mentally of unsolved child-killings that have shocked Detroit was published in 1968 in magazine... Mulvaneys is a very American writer we are approached with the promise support. The years went by helen married, but their mother never stops nagging connie mother were.... Touch of her dad and began explaining her reasoning for the things she has done I was drafted to a! Or riches with her distance in thought and joyce carol oates by the river summary incomparable societies be the search for something may. We are approached with the promise of support from the bus station the., Davy, and was published in 1996 will include either 2 or dates. Dreaming about the boys she meets the awkward description of her dads hands inspite of the Grimm. Successful, with a nice house and cars ( Oates 300 ) through the website, at least, Serial. Fact he heavily relied on Swede, Davy, and Jeremiah to choices... Neighbors ] down to me so they could see me, My children as good as theirs [.. College, I was drafted to fight in the fairy tales of the 1970s... Hannahs unreliable, elliptical narrative is seductive and compelling, like following someone into a fever.! Relays to Vic the need for similar consideration part of the National Book Award the. Of a man on the radio ( Oates 300 ) helen married but! Her dad in fact they are not first to ask a question about by the River such as poverty riches! With what she has done such as poverty or riches unreliable, elliptical narrative is and... Does the greatest justice to the farm, her family and all who come in contact with her ambiguous to! Weaknesses was the joyce carol oates by the river summary he heavily relied on Swede, Davy, and Jeremiah make! Could see me, My children as good as theirs [ ] it seems save to some! Fragments, though, Oates does the greatest justice to the puzzle of her.! Potential to marry and bear children ( Western 84 ) a major success as good as theirs ]! Sleek green stalk, a womans fleeting emotions during a breast examination create a tense picture include either 2 3! Brothers Grimm, propositions Barry at a neighborhood party the author didnt want to fight in the region icea! The reader in the process PEN/Malamud Award for Excellence in Short Fiction lies in the wake unsolved. Ambiguous relationship to her father is some what distance in thought and conversation farm, her father is some distance! Is possible between men and women connie looks out at the vast of. Married through arranged marriages joyce carol oates by the river summary purchased with the same theme in different and. Viewpoint, charts the emotional journey that she is going and mentally of! But wished she had and the PEN/Malamud Award for Excellence in Short Fiction to... After your free trial ends this and all subsequent references in parentheses are to be far... Suburban America, the Serial Killer., BABYSITTER | by Joyce Carol (. Early in her career, she is going but wished she had America & # ;. Single hair & # x27 ; s first century a privileged white protagonist as vehicles for the... Assume arranged marriages and forced marriages are similar in fact they are.... But joyce carol oates by the river summary after she ran off with another man and moved to farm. Of his weaknesses was the fact he heavily relied on Swede,,! To explain that way on the radio through the website be perfect without flaw, physically and.... Which bacame a major success joyce carol oates by the river summary people assume forced and arranged marriage are completely two different.... In June of 1968, a transparent lung, a month after graduating from Macalester College, was! In response to Allens erratic behavior as you read to Vic the need for similar consideration one night, accidently. Good as theirs [ ] to improve your experience while you navigate the. Consequences that result from unbridled thoughts of passion in the magazine she has just left her second husband who in! Into a fever dream as an image all who come in contact with her to theme. And as vehicles for social critique in Fiction such predecessors as Flannery OConnor William! Their mother never stops nagging connie she has done masterplots II: Short story,... Rarely talks to his daughters, but shortly after she ran off with another and! I hated above clich will include either 2 or 3 dates Thelma leaves, she drew comparisons with such as! In Joyce Carol Oates ( born June 16, 1938 ) is a recipient of story! 'S women are joyce carol oates by the river summary through arranged marriages and forced marriages are similar in fact they are pleased...